As you probably know from personal experience, people are pretty attached to their phones. We use them for many tasks throughout the day, from driving to listening to music to shopping. Smart companies figured this out a long time ago, and began to develop apps to help engage customers and market and sell more products. If your favorite brand hasn’t created an app yet (and let’s be honest: that’s unlikely), they’re surely working on one.

So where does that leave the good old-fashioned web browser and websites? Does an app automatically offer a better user experience than a browser? Can you do everything that you need to within an app? Will users soon abandon the world wide web altogether in favor of apps?

We’re taking a closer look at those questions in this article. Here are some things to think about when considering using a browser vs. app.

The Big Differences: Apps vs. Browser

The differences between an app and a browser are significant and can impact user experience, accessibility, and functionality. In fact, the differences might be more important than you think. Whether it’s the push notifications, tailored features, or user-friendly interfaces, both apps and websites offer valuable tools that cater to different aspects of our online lives.

Platforms and Accessibility

App: Applications are standalone software designed for specific devices (mobile phones, tablets, desktops). They need to be downloaded and installed from an app store or marketplace. Many software companies make app versions of their products so users can access their software’s functionality on mobile devices.

Browser: A web browser is software that allows users to access and navigate the internet. It can run on any device with internet connectivity and does not require installation in the same way apps do. Furthermore, the layout and dimensions of these websites automatically adjust to fit a smart phone’s screen.With a website, you can type the URL into your laptop or desktop web browser to see the identical visuals magnified to fit a computer screen.

Usage and Frequency

App: Typically used for specific tasks or services, especially if they are utilized frequently. They are designed for regular interactions and quick access. For example, checking your banking daily, tracking calories throughout meals, or automating emails for marketing outreach (such as the handy tools in Respona).

Browser: Used for a broader range of tasks, including research, browsing multiple sites, and accessing various online services in one place. Websites offer a deeper user experience, so you might use them to download more robust information, pull reporting, or view academic articles. Tasks that are more complex in nature or require more documentation will likely benefit from a mobile website in a productivity web browser.

Related Post: The Best Browsers for Overall Productivity

Performance and Speed

App: Generally offers faster load times because they store data locally on your own device. This means that the most used features are normally front and center and easy to use, and you can access information faster. Apps also tend to streamline information and navigation so that key information is more available, but that means there are some things you can’t take advantage of in an app.

Browser: May experience slower load times due to reliance on internet connectivity and remote servers, especially with complex websites. In many cases, there will be functionality that you can’t access at all without an internet connection. Furthermore, since browsers run on your own device, performance will vary based on things like your own storage and which programs you’re running.

Smart Mobile Features

App: Software applications offer powerful features created specifically for mobile interactions. Designed with mobile or other device interfaces in mind, typically featuring touch-friendly navigation, larger buttons, and simplified layouts for ease of use. For instance, think of how many apps you use that incorporate your phone’s camera, including social media. Today’s apps use real-time photos from your device for everything from baking to gardening to antique-shopping.

Additionally, apps often utilize unique features like push notifications, GPS integration, offline access, and many more tools that make the app experience faster and more convenient. Many apps offer options that are not available on the website at all, or tools that complement the main functions of the original website.

Browser: Websites can display complex information and layouts, providing a more extensive view of content, which is ideal for multitasking or more detailed browsing. In our above examples, for instance, you can use an app to snap a photo of a plant in order to find out how to care for it - but you can research more about the plant, see other people’s photos, or download detailed care instructions to print on a website.

When it comes to direct access to device hardware, websites are more limited. Though they can offer a versatile platform for accessing a wide range of services, they don’t always have a single interface like an app might. In fact, many websites direct users to an app in order to take advantage of more robust features.

Updates and Maintenance

App: Applications typically require manual updates through the app store, which can add new features or fix bugs. Users need to manage updates regularly. Most apps will alert you to new updates so that you can take the proper steps. Some apps won’t work on outdated operating systems, such as on a phone that’s too old.

Browser: On the web, updates are normally automatic, ensuring users always have the latest version without needing to take action. These updates can fix bugs, enhance security, and more. Using the latest version of websites is a great way to keep information private and remain protected online, and websites roll these out automatically without you having to worry about it.

Connectivity

App: Many apps offer offline functionality, allowing users to access content without an internet connection. This is especially helpful for people who may not have consistent access to the internet or travel a lot.

Browser: Generally, websites need an internet connection to function, though some browsers can cache data for limited offline use. You can also download information and store it on your device, or use some other work-arounds, but your real-time access and ability to use tools is certainly more limited offline.

Notifications

App: Most apps send push notifications directly to user devices, providing real-time updates and reminders. Everything from shopping to banking to project management apps use notifications to send real-time information that keeps you constantly updated. Though you can manage these notifications in your device settings, most apps are designed to send notifications.

Browser: Mobile websites, even in a productivity web browser, do not offer the immediacy of app-based notifications. We’ll expand on this below, but that could be a good thing or a bad thing depending on your preferences.

Security

App: Apps are vetted by app stores for safety, but the system is far from fool-proof. The bigger issue, though, is that once you’ve downloaded an app onto your device, the company has a lot of leeway to collect information that is harder for websites to obtain. For example, app owners can understand your approximate location or what other devices are connected to your wifi. You don’t have much control over what happens to your data from there.

Browser: Websites cannot “spy” or track your activity as easily as apps can. There are more rules requiring permission for tracking or saving data. Plus, the top websites and browsers employ some of the best security engineers in the world. Plus, browsers have their own security measures that apply to any site you visit, so there is an added layer of protection vs. using an app.

Related Post: How to Secure Your Online Accounts

Personal Factors to Consider: Browser vs. Apps

Despite the typical differences in an app vs. a browser, there are more nuanced implications on user experience, efficiency, and overall satisfaction. Both platforms offer unique advantages that cater to different needs and preferences that are person-dependent. Let’s explore some key factors that you’ll want to consider in your own app vs. browser decisions.

Frequency of Use

One of the first considerations when deciding between an app and a website is how often you plan to use the service. Apps are typically designed for frequent use, providing a quick and easy way to access content and features. If you find yourself returning to a service multiple times a day, an app can save you time and effort with its easy accessibility. Conversely, if your usage is sporadic or more research-oriented, a website might suffice, allowing you to access the service without the need to download or update software.

Specific App or Web Features

Apps often come equipped with features tailored to mobile devices, such as GPS integration, camera access, and offline functionality, enhancing the overall user experience. For instance, many social media apps allow users to post photos directly from their camera, while certain banking apps offer mobile check deposits.

On the other hand, websites can provide a richer experience for complex tasks, such as detailed analytics or extensive content browsing, which may be cumbersome on a smaller screen. The choice between an app and a website can depend on the specific features you require for your tasks.

Speed

For most people, speed is a critical factor in overall user experience. Apps generally tend to load faster than websites, as they store data locally on your device, reducing the need for constant internet connectivity. This is particularly beneficial for users who require quick access to information or services, such as navigation or messaging. For example, think of the speed that you depend on from your GPS apps. Not getting the directions quickly enough could lead to heading the wrong way or even wasting precious time in traffic.

Websites, however, can be more versatile in terms of updates and new features, as they don't require user downloads. If speed is essential to your tasks, particularly when on the go, an app may be the better option.

User Interface (UI)

The user interface of a website versus an app can greatly influence your choice. Apps are designed with mobile usability in mind, often featuring intuitive navigation, larger touch targets, and streamlined layouts that cater to smaller screens. This can make performing tasks more straightforward and enjoyable. Websites, while sometimes more complex, can provide a more comprehensive view of information, with the ability to display larger amounts of data simultaneously. Depending on the nature of your tasks, you may prefer the simplicity of an app or the depth of a website.

Notifications

Push notifications are a key advantage of apps, allowing users to receive real-time updates and alerts directly on their devices. This feature is particularly useful for time-sensitive tasks, such as messaging or reminders for appointments. Apps can keep you engaged and informed without having to actively check the service. Websites, while they can offer email notifications or alerts through browser settings, often lack the immediacy that apps provide. If staying informed and connected is a priority for you, the notification capabilities of an app can be a significant advantage.

On the other hand, some people get easily distracted by apps and endless notifications. While many people enjoy staying in the loop and constantly connected, others find non-stop pings from various apps very disruptive. If you’re a person who likes to periodically check in on things like social media or news sites, you’re likely better off using a website where you can control the flow of information and the amount that you consume at a given time.

Obviously, the decision to use an app or a website depends on personal preferences and specific needs. There is no “right” answer - it’s dependent on your own situation and comfort.  Advanced users might benefit from the convenience and speed of an app, while those requiring detailed information and features may find a website more suitable. Understanding the unique advantages of each platform can help you maximize your efficiency and enjoyment in your digital interactions.

Related Post: How to Get a Notification Aggregator for Desktop

Why Companies Want You To “Use an App for That”

Apps can offer a faster and more user-friendly experience, so a lot of companies want you to use an app instead of the website for personal satisfaction and convenience. After all, who wouldn’t want their customers to have a better experience? A better experience leads to repeat purchases and personal recommendations.

However, there are some other factors in play and it’s good to understand them. The truth is that companies can mine a lot more user data from an app than a website. When you download an app, they will be ever-present in your device and capture a lot of information about you and what you do.

For example, a real estate platform (such as Zillow or Trulia) will advertise their app on their web pages. Then, once you’ve downloaded the app and started to use it, “they” are present throughout your real estate journey. It’s as though they are in your pocket when you drive around looking at homes, attend an open house, or look at new properties while lying in bed at night. Some of these companies have partnered with GPS platforms, so that they can target people with ads about properties in their specific location. Mobile data is a goldmine for companies, as well as for third-parties who buy that data.

Here’s another example. If you use the LinkedIn app frequently, then the contact list that you maintain there can provide valuable insights to other platforms. LinkedIn can actually learn more about people and their contacts from their calendar or email. And obviously, advertisers are willing to pay a pretty penny for such valuable information. Factor in access to your camera, microphone, calendar, address book, etc. - and you can see how your device provides a wealth of highly coveted information from a single location.

It’s important to keep in mind that though companies probably do want you to have a great experience, that is only part of their motivation for pushing apps vs. a browser. In today’s data-rich landscape, there’s a lot more to the story. The information they collect from your app use can be used in marketing or sold, expanding their revenue base in multiple ways. The more data they collect now, the more they can use it in the future in new and innovative ways.

Make sure to follow our blog for more productivity-enhancing tips and tech trends to keep an eye on.